McAfee Internet Security 2014

McAfee Internet Security 2014 Review: Internet Security Software

Internet Security Software
Visit McAfee Internet Security 2014 Website
Bottom Line:
Standard PC security with an updated interface while retaining the same features as the previous version
Full Review:
4 2014-07-18 15:53:50 [Editor's Note: McAfee is offering $45 off Internet Security to NextAdvisor visitors, no coupon code required. Just follow any link to McAfee from NextAdvisor to receive the discount.]

McAfee Internet Security 2014 boasts an updated interface and a powerful 2-way firewall to provide standard PC security without many bells and whistles.


The simple installation process continues to be one of the highlights of McAfee's software. Following purchase and registration, you can download and install the program directly from the website without waiting for an email confirmation like with several other security suites we've reviewed. The file installation is quick and painless so you're able to use McAfee within minutes of purchasing.


After struggling with an outdated interface for years, McAfee has given its interface a facelift. The new interface maintains the same color scheme as previous years, but creates a more visually appealing look with large buttons and improved usability. Compared to the flashier offerings of Norton or Avast!, more improvements are needed but this is a marked change from a software that has long held out on a much-needed overhaul.

The home screen displays a color-coded bar at the top which tells you the current status of your computer. The rest of the screen is laid out with four large buttons (Virus and Spyware Protection, Web and Email Protection, McAfee Updates and Your Subscription) beside a row of 3 smaller buttons (Data Protection and Backup, PC and Home Network Tools and Parental Controls). The right sidebar includes links to Home, Navigation and Help as well as a box at the bottom that cycles through pertinent information from your latest scan.

Though the new interface certainly offers better organization and usability, it can still be somewhat confusing to navigate to certain features. The Navigation page — which consists of links to every feature hidden within the button categories on the home page as well as a couple of random extras — seems unnecessary and just serves to highlight the confusion.

Special Features

McAfee's 2014 Internet security software is pretty much the same when it comes to features as previous years. Some features are fairly robust, such as the Parental Controls — which allow you to create a custom profile or use a standard setting based on age as well as set an Internet usage schedule — or the 2-way Firewall which provides powerful protection against viruses and malware.

SiteAdvisor is also a nice feature for boosting browsing security. This browser application provides a color-coded rating of websites in the toolbar as well as beside links in search results pages that lets you know how safe it is before visiting. Currently it only works for Microsoft Internet Explorer and Mozilla Firefox, but hopefully an extension to Google Chrome will be offered in the future.

Other features are less convenient. File Shredder is a good feature to have, but the explanations for the 5 shred types (such as, "Safe — It's secure" followed by "Comprehensive — It's very secure") seem silly and don't offer much explanation as to what the real difference is between the different types. Similarly, the Defragmenter link in the Navigation Center merely opens up your computer's defrag program. Good to have if someone is unfamiliar with this tool, but otherwise a waste of program space.

Antimalware/Antivirus Tests* McAfee
11/10 Dynamic Test N/A
06/11 Dynamic Test
12/11 Dynamic Test
07/12 Dynamic Test
12/12 Dynamic Test
07/13 Dynamic Test
12/13 Dynamic Test
07/14 Dynamic Test
Historical Average

McAfee has a spotted past when it comes to independent testing from AV-Comparatives, an antivirus testing organization. In the most recent Whole-Product Dynamic Test, which looks at how the different components work together against viruses, McAfee scored 1 out of 3 stars and was noted in the test report as being downgraded specifically due to the high number of wrongfully blocked sites or files. McAfee's historical average for this test is only 1 out of 3 stars, and it has earned 0 stars twice. Part of why it ranks so low is because the software is designed to warn you about malicious web addresses that you might be visiting, not block them, which is one of the key components to the test. The software also historically tends to be sensitive and blocks several safe sites or files.

In our own testing of the software, it performed exactly as it should and blocked every test virus we threw at it. The 2-way firewall performs at a rate similar to what you get from the feature-rich competition, which is a definite advantage for McAfee.

Performance Tests* McAfee
11/10 Performance Test
07/11 Performance Test
11/11 Performance Test
07/12 Performance Test
10/12 Performance Test
04/13 Performance Test
11/13 Performance Test
05/14 Performance Test
Historical Average

Due to its simplicity, McAfee is relatively light on its feet and great at not slowing down your computer and keeping things running smoothly. Despite a score of 1 out of 3 stars in the most recent AV-Comparatives Performance test, our use of the software saw no significant performance or lag issues. The relative lack of annoying pop-ups or notifications was also a relief and we appreciated McAfee's quiet, unobtrusive performance.


Unfortunately, while McAfee has redesigned their interface, the features offered remain largely the same. If you're looking for perks like a secluded browsing window for banking and online shopping or special protection for social networking, which are becoming standard for software security suites, McAfee will only disappoint. The software continues to do what McAfee is best known for, which is protect against viruses and malware and help your computer run more efficiently. If this is all you're looking for, then McAfee is the security software for you.

System Requirements: Windows XP, Windows Vista, Windows 7 or Windows 8

AV-Comparatives ratings on a variety of tasks related to the antivirus and antimalware product. "Known Malware" refers to a product's ability to catch pre-identified viruses, while "Unknown Malware" refers to its ability to detect brand new viruses. Older scores may reflect previous software versions.

Visit McAfee Internet Security 2014 Website | Compare to Other Internet Security Software

Service Details:

Price:$44.99/yr for up to 3 PCs
(with $45 discount)
Ease of Use:Revamped interface enhances usability
Special Features:Parental controls; antispam; 1GB backup; file shredder, 2-way firewall; SiteAdvisor
Personal Information Manager:None
Anti-malware/Antivirus Score*:
System Performance Score**:

*Averaged 2010/2011 scores for each company's antivirus/anti-malware product by independent testing agency AV-Comparatives. Score indicates overall effectiveness in a variety of tests over time. † indicates that company did not take part in all tests. See reviews for details.

**Score indicates impact of antivirus product on system performance. Average of performance tests by AV-Comparatives.

NextAdvisor Internet Security Software Blog Headlines

Social Media Scams: 5 Tips for Staying Safe While You Share
You see the warnings all the time. Beware of the Facebook color scam going around! Don't click links from fishy-looking emails asking you to log into your Twitter account! Social media is impossible to escape, but with its proliferation comes a slew of new dangers and safety concerns. The days of communication on the Internet [...]

UPS Security Breach Affects 51 Stores in 24 States
United Parcel Service (UPS) customers might want to check their bank statements after the shipment and logistics company announced that 51 of its U.S. stores located throughout 24 states were breached by malware. UPS said the computer virus was not identified by current antivirus software. UPS customers who used a credit or debit card at one of [...]

Watch Out for the Facebook Color Scam
Wouldn't it be cool if your Facebook profile had a pretty purple background or the top bar could be changed to some color other than the basic blue? For almost as long as it has existed, users have lamented the lack of customization features such as this one. Scammers and spammers have been cashing in [...]

McAfee Internet Security 2014 Forum Posts

About UsBlogContact Us Forums Terms & Privacy PolicyAffiliate ProgramSite Map is a BBB Accredited Information Bureau in San Francisco, CA

Advertiser Disclosure: is a consumer information site that offers free, independent reviews and ratings of online services. We receive advertising revenue from most but not all of the companies whose products and services we review. For credit cards, we review cards from all of the top 10 US issuers by purchase volume (according to Issue 1035 of The Nilson Report, Feb 2014) excluding issuers that require additional accounts to be a cardholder and private label issuers. We may also review cards from other issuers in select cases. We do not review all products in a given category. We are independently owned and operated and all opinions expressed on this site are our own.